Riot police deployed at Poland's Constitutional Tribunal as dispute over its leadership escalates
On October 30, 2026, Judge Anna Korwin-Piotrowska, one of the judges elected by the Sejm this year, ordered the one-month suspension of Constitutional Tribunal President Bogdan Swieczkowski and Vice-President Bartlomiej Sochanski, according to the International Commission of Jurists. Riot police were deployed at the court in Warsaw the same day.[1][2]
The government of Prime Minister Donald Tusk defends the move as restoring the rule of law. Swieczkowski, six other judges and President Karol Nawrocki reject it as unlawful, and no court has ruled on the dispute.[2][1]
Suspension and police deployment
According to the Warsaw police, as reported by the ICJ, officers arrived at the Tribunal after Korwin-Piotrowska reported possible threats to the safety of judges and staff. BBC News reported that riot police were deployed to prevent demonstrators from entering the building as supporters of the opposition Law and Justice party (PiS) gathered outside.[1][2]
The same day, Justice Minister and Prosecutor General Waldemar Zurek said he had asked for Swieczkowski and Sochanski to be stripped of immunity from prosecution, and the ICJ reported that he submitted five motions to the Tribunal seeking consent to open criminal proceedings against them.[2][1]
Government and opposition accounts
Tusk wrote that restoring the rule of law was the government's duty and required decisive action, and Zurek later told broadcaster TVN, as reported by Notes from Poland, that Korwin-Piotrowska's actions were the only way to rebuild the independence of the tribunal.[2][3]
The Tribunal, in a social media post quoted by the BBC, said the two judges remained its legally appointed senior justices and that those taking part were committing the crime of a coup d'etat. The ICJ reported that Swieczkowski and six other judges declared the orders unlawful while Korwin-Piotrowska assumed the role of acting head.[2][1]
President Nawrocki entered the court building, according to his chief of staff, and Notes from Poland reported that he clashed physically and verbally with Korwin-Piotrowska there. The ICJ reported that his office called the events a forcible takeover of a constitutional organ and said it intends to file a criminal complaint against three of the newly elected judges. Former Justice Minister Zbigniew Ziobro called the move a criminal attack on the constitutional order.[2][3][1][4]
Background to the dispute
The ICJ reported that the Sejm has elected eight judges since March 2026 and that Nawrocki received the oath of three but refused it from the other five. ICJ Secretary-General Santiago Canton said that refusal violates international standards, and that the suspension carried out with police involvement also contravenes international standards on judicial independence.[1]
Lawyer Marcin Matczak, a critic of the PiS-era reforms, wrote that the action buries the court and the rule of law issue for two decades. Maciej Nowicki of the Helsinki Foundation for Human Rights told the Associated Press the legal basis for the suspension was doubtful and the police presence escalated emotions on both sides.[2][4]
The November 3 general assembly
On November 3 the eight judges elected this year met as a general assembly of the Tribunal and decided that a quorum had been reached, although the seven judges appointed under the former government did not attend, Notes from Poland reported. The assembly adopted a draft 2027 budget and moved forward with disciplinary proceedings against Swieczkowski.[3]
Swieczkowski rejected the legitimacy of the meeting, according to Notes from Poland citing Polsat News, and Nawrocki accused the government of illegally taking over the Tribunal. The record does not establish whether the suspensions or the assembly's decisions are legally valid.[3]
What the first record did not show
Open questions as of Nov 5, 2026, when IPR first recorded this story. Updates since then may answer some of them.
- Whether any court will rule on the validity of the suspensions.
- Whether the November 3 assembly's decisions will be recognised.
- Whether criminal proceedings against the Tribunal's leadership will go ahead.
The record
- Event type
- Official action or statement[1]Stated by International Commission of Jurists, independent analysis, Nov 3, 2026
- Means
- None[2]
- Target type
- Government facility[2]
- Occurred, start
- Oct 30, 2026[1]Stated by International Commission of Jurists, independent analysis, Nov 3, 2026
- First reported
- Oct 30, 2026The date of the earliest cited source
- Primary place
- Constitutional Tribunal building, Warsaw (site)[2]Stated by BBC News, official account, Oct 30, 2026
- Next expected milestone
- General Assembly of Constitutional Tribunal judges on the motions to lift the immunity of Swieczkowski and Sochanski[9]Stated by Rzeczpospolita, official account, Nov 12, 2026Also stated: General Assembly of Constitutional Tribunal judges on the motions to lift immunity[5], stated by Rzeczpospolita (PAP), official account, Nov 6, 2026
- Next milestone date
- Nov 17, 2026[5]Stated by Rzeczpospolita (PAP), official account, Nov 6, 2026
Each value is what a cited source stated, with its source number. Where sources give different figures, the latest official account is listed first and every other figure is listed with it. A figure for one part of an event, such as one strike in a campaign, is listed as that part and never as the total.
Case and outcome record
| Date | Stage | Who | Court, office or agency | As the source states it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oct 30, 2026 | Incident | Constitutional Tribunal of Poland | ordered the suspension of the President of the Constitutional Tribunal[1] | |
| Nov 10, 2026 | Appeal decided | Supreme Court of Poland | uchylił to postanowienie, a następnie decyzje o odsunięciu obu sędziów od obowiązków[8] |
One row per stage for each person, as sources report it. A stage a source only expects is not listed until it happens.
IPR records what each source says and who said it. A cited statement shows that a source said it, not that it is true. Hover a number to see the exact words quoted from that source. See something wrong? Use a flag to report it.