Police and students clash near Jamia Millia Islamia in Delhi over citizenship law, December 13, 2019
On December 13, 2019, a student protest at Jamia Millia Islamia university in New Delhi against India's new citizenship law turned violent when police used tear gas and batons, according to the Guardian and the New Indian Express. The New Indian Express reported that some protesters threw stones at police and that 50 students were detained; the Guardian put the number detained at more than 50.[1][2]
The protest on December 13
The New Indian Express reported that the protest, led by the All India Students' Association, turned violent after protesters from Jamia Millia Islamia were held back from walking towards Parliament. It reported that some protesters threw stones at police, who responded with a baton charge and tear gas, and that several journalists caught in the clash were manhandled.[2]
Several students were injured and admitted to Holy Family Hospital after the baton charge, the New Indian Express reported, and students alleged that police also used tear gas to stop their march. The paper also reported that media personnel were beaten and harassed later that day, allegedly by students, and that protesters demanded the release of detained students.[2]
The law and the wider protests
The Guardian reported that under the new law, Hindu, Christian, Jain, Buddhist and Sikh migrants from Bangladesh, Pakistan and Afghanistan could claim Indian citizenship, and that the same would not apply to Muslims. Critics accused the BJP government of passing a law that discriminates against Muslims, the Guardian reported, and the United Nations human rights office said the law was fundamentally discriminatory in nature. Several petitions challenging its constitutional validity were filed in the Supreme Court that day.[1]
Protests were also under way elsewhere in India. The Guardian reported that two protesters in Assam died after being caught in police fire on December 12, and that the unrest led Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe to cancel a planned visit to India.[1]
Later court proceedings
On February 4, 2023, a Delhi court discharged Sharjeel Imam and Asif Iqbal Tanha in a case related to violence at Jamia Millia Islamia in December 2019; Scroll reported that the trial court had held the activists were made scapegoats because the actual perpetrators could not be held. On March 28, 2023, the Delhi High Court partially set aside that order and framed charges against nine of the 11 accused, according to Scroll.[3][4]
Scroll reported that this case pertains to violence on the campus on December 15, 2019, when Delhi Police were accused of entering the campus and using excessive force, and police said their action was justified because protesters had allegedly injured officers and set buses on fire. The record does not establish whether any criminal case covers the December 13 clash itself.[4]
The record
- Event type
- Protest or civil disorder[1]Stated by The Guardian, witness account, Dec 13, 2019
- Target type
- Public gathering or event[1]
- Occurred, start
- Dec 13, 2019[1][2]Stated by The New Indian Express, witness account, Dec 13, 2019
- First reported
- Dec 13, 2019The date of the earliest cited source
- Primary place
- Jamia Millia Islamia (site)[1]Stated by The Guardian, witness account, Dec 13, 2019
- State or province
- Delhi[1]Stated by The Guardian, witness account, Dec 13, 2019
- Missing or held
- 50[2]Stated by The New Indian Express, witness account, Dec 13, 2019Also stated: more than 50[1], stated by The Guardian, witness account, Dec 13, 2019
Each value is what a cited source stated, with its source number. Where sources give different figures, the latest official account is listed first and every other figure is listed with it. A figure for one part of an event, such as one strike in a campaign, is listed as that part and never as the total.
Case and outcome record
| Date | Stage | Who | Court, office or agency | As the source states it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 13, 2019 | Incident | New Delhi | AISA-led protest turned violent after protesters were held back from walking towards Parliament[2] |
One row per stage for each person, as sources report it. A stage a source only expects is not listed until it happens.
IPR records what each source says and who said it. A cited statement shows that a source said it, not that it is true. Hover a number to see the exact words quoted from that source. See something wrong? Use a flag to report it.