Two assailants kill a Jersey City detective and three people at a kosher supermarket, December 10, 2019
On December 10, 2019, David N. Anderson and Francine Graham killed Jersey City Police Detective Joseph Seals in Bay View Cemetery and then shot and killed three people inside the JC Kosher Supermarket on Martin Luther King Drive, according to the New Jersey Attorney General. Both assailants were killed by police after an engagement that ended at about 3:47 p.m.[1]
State and federal officials described the attack as fueled by anti-Semitism and anti-law enforcement beliefs. In November 2021 a state grand jury declined to charge the officers who shot the assailants.[2][3][1]
The attack
According to the Attorney General's account, after Seals was killed in the cemetery, Anderson parked a white U-Haul van across from the supermarket at about 12:21 p.m., got out with a rifle and began shooting. Graham also entered the store. A survivor escaped shortly after the gunfire began, and the two assailants remained inside for the rest of the incident.[1]
Officers near the scene responded within minutes and came under fire, and two officers suffered non-fatal gunshot wounds. A police armored vehicle broke through the entrance at about 3:25 p.m., and the incident ended about 22 minutes later.[1]
Investigation and motive
On December 12, 2019, Attorney General Gurbir Grewal said the evidence pointed toward acts of hate and that the attack was being investigated as potential domestic terrorism fueled by anti-Semitism and anti-law enforcement beliefs. Mayor Steve Fulop said surveillance video made clear the attackers targeted the Jewish market. FBI Newark asked the public to submit photos and videos.[2][4]
Grewal said the attackers had expressed interest in the Black Hebrew Israelites, and that both were also prime suspects in the killing of a livery driver in Bayonne days earlier. Officials' statements describe interest in the group; the record does not establish that either assailant was a member or that any group directed the attack.[2]
In January 2020, U.S. Attorney Craig Carpenito said the pair targeted Jewish victims and law enforcement and planned greater attacks, and that they had researched a Jewish center in Bayonne online. CBS reported that investigators found a bomb in their van and five weapons in the store, and the U.S. attorney's office said it was confident the two acted alone. FBI official Gregory Ehrie said nothing before the attack had put either on authorities' radar.[3]
The encounter with Detective Seals
Why Seals encountered the pair is not established. Officials speculated that he may have stopped the van because it matched a description linked to the Bayonne killing, and Carpenito speculated that the encounter forced the pair into action before a broader attack using the bomb.[3]
Grand jury review of the police shooting
Under New Jersey law, the Attorney General's Office of Public Integrity and Accountability investigated the police shooting of the assailants and presented it to a state grand jury. The grand jury concluded on November 15, 2021, and voted no bill, finding that the officers' actions were justified and no charges should be filed.[1]
The record
- Event type
- Attack[1]Stated by New Jersey Office of Attorney General, official account, Nov 17, 2021
- Means
- Firearm, Explosive or IED[3][1]
- Target type
- Business or retail, Law enforcement or military[2][3]
- Occurred, start
- Dec 10, 2019[1]Stated by New Jersey Office of Attorney General, official account, Nov 17, 2021
- First reported
- Dec 12, 2019The date of the earliest cited source
- Primary place
- JC Kosher Supermarket, 223 Martin Luther King Drive, Jersey City (site)[1]Stated by New Jersey Office of Attorney General, official account, Nov 17, 2021
- State or province
- New Jersey[1]Stated by New Jersey Office of Attorney General, official account, Nov 17, 2021
- Killed
- No source has stated a total. Figures for parts of the event:3[1], killed three people in the store, stated by New Jersey Office of Attorney General, official account, Nov 17, 20211[1], killed Jersey City Police Detective Joseph Seals in Bay View Cemetery, stated by New Jersey Office of Attorney General, official account, Nov 17, 2021
- Injured
- No source has stated a total. Figures for parts of the event:2[1], Two officers suffered non-fatal gunshot wounds, stated by New Jersey Office of Attorney General, official account, Nov 17, 2021
Each value is what a cited source stated, with its source number. Where sources give different figures, the latest official account is listed first and every other figure is listed with it. A figure for one part of an event, such as one strike in a campaign, is listed as that part and never as the total.
Case and outcome record
| Date | Stage | Who | Court, office or agency | As the source states it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 10, 2019 | Incident | Jersey City, New Jersey | Anderson and Graham shot and killed three people in the store[1] | |
| Dec 10, 2019 | Subject died | David N. Anderson | New Jersey Office of Attorney General | the officers who shot Anderson and Graham were justified[1] |
| Dec 10, 2019 | Subject died | Francine Graham | New Jersey Office of Attorney General | the officers who shot Anderson and Graham were justified[1] |
| Nov 15, 2021 | Official report or review released | New Jersey state grand jury | no charges should be filed against the officers[1] |
One row per stage for each person, as sources report it. A stage a source only expects is not listed until it happens.
IPR records what each source says and who said it. A cited statement shows that a source said it, not that it is true. Hover a number to see the exact words quoted from that source. See something wrong? Use a flag to report it.