Today: Mon Nov 16, 2026MethodologyCorrectionsSource policyAboutResearch Desk
Home › Indo-Pacific Alliances and Defense › Crowd-funded public inquiry calls for Australia to end the...
Indo-Pacific Alliances and DefenseQuiet

Crowd-funded public inquiry calls for Australia to end the AUKUS nuclear submarine plan

A crowd-funded public inquiry led by former Labor minister Peter Garrett and former defence chief Admiral Chris Barrie released a report on November 4, 2026, calling the AUKUS nuclear submarine plan the worst, riskiest and most costly defence decision ever made by an Australian government. The Guardian reported that the inquiry recommended suspending plans for new bases and holding a royal commission.[1]

Compiled by IPR3 sources21 attributed claimsUpdated Nov 8, 2026
Report a problem
Peter Garrett in a debate in Ostrava, Czechia, in 2017 (file photo)
Peter Garrett in a debate in Ostrava, Czechia, in 2017 (file photo). Photo: Xmetov (CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons)

The government stands by the agreement. The Guardian reported that a spokesperson for Defence Minister Richard Marles called AUKUS a core pillar of the government's national security policy, and that ministers dismissed the inquiry as a stitch-up by its critics.[1]

How the inquiry worked

According to PS News, the inquiry was coordinated by the Australian Peace and Security Forum, funded through crowd sourcing, and launched on 3 June. PS News reported that its hearings heard from more than 150 witnesses and that more than 1000 written submissions were received. The inquiry is not a government or parliamentary body.[2]

What the report says

The report, as quoted by PS News, found the planned delivery schedule for the Virginia-class and SSN-AUKUS submarines to be at best problematic and most likely unachievable, and said the agreement would let the UK and US walk away without delivering any submarines. PS News reported that the inquiry said Australia had already spent about $9.2 billion supporting the US and UK industrial bases and starting a local shipyard.[2]

The Guardian reported that the inquiry estimates an additional $180bn will be needed to deal with nuclear waste, and that no official estimate for waste costs has been published. At the National Press Club, Garrett said Labor had failed to conduct a thorough review of the agreement, and Barrie called on the government to scrap the submarine plan.[1]

Government response

The defence minister's spokesperson said Australia confronts the most challenging strategic circumstances since the second world war. The Guardian reported that Labor argues AUKUS was considered in the government's defence strategic review, and that the government's preferred measure of the deal's total cost is 0.15% of GDP over its lifetime. The Guardian also reported that the first Virginia-class submarine is due to arrive in 2032.[1]

Criticism of the inquiry

Jennifer Parker of the University of Western Australia's Defence and Security Institute wrote that the inquiry takes an alarmist approach and shows a limited understanding of maritime strategy and defence acquisition. She noted that four of its five commissioners had previously criticised AUKUS, that it made 17 recommendations, and that it offers no viable replacement for the program.[3]

The record

Event type
Other[1]Stated by The Guardian, alternate view, Nov 4, 2026
Means
None[1]
Target type
Other[1]
Occurred, start
Nov 4, 2026[1]Stated by The Guardian, official account, Nov 4, 2026
First reported
Nov 4, 2026The date of the earliest cited source
Primary place
Australia (country)[1]Stated by The Guardian, alternate view, Nov 4, 2026

Each value is what a cited source stated, with its source number. Where sources give different figures, the latest official account is listed first and every other figure is listed with it. A figure for one part of an event, such as one strike in a campaign, is listed as that part and never as the total.

Case and outcome record

DateStageWhoCourt, office or agencyAs the source states it
Nov 4, 2026Official report or review releasedAUKUS public inquiry (crowd-funded, coordinated by the Australian Peace and Security Forum)the worst, riskiest and most costly defence decision ever made by an Australian government[1]

One row per stage for each person, as sources report it. A stage a source only expects is not listed until it happens.

IPR records what each source says and who said it. A cited statement shows that a source said it, not that it is true. Hover a number to see the exact words quoted from that source. See something wrong? Use a flag to report it.

What the record does not show yet

  • Whether the government will formally respond to the report's recommendations.
  • The official estimated cost of nuclear waste disposal, which has not been published.